BlurMail vs SimpleLogin: Disposable Email vs Email Aliasing
SimpleLogin is an open-source email aliasing service acquired by Proton, offering permanent forwarding addresses as a privacy layer. BlurMail takes a different approach with truly disposable, auto-expiring addresses. These services solve related but distinct problems.
Overview
SimpleLogin creates email aliases that forward to your real inbox, allowing you to use unique addresses for every service while keeping your real email hidden. It integrates with Proton Mail and offers browser extensions. BlurMail provides standalone disposable email addresses through a native mobile app, with their own inbox, push notifications, and auto-expiration.
Privacy and Security
SimpleLogin is strong on privacy as an open-source, Proton-backed service. Aliases are permanent and can reply through them, maintaining your anonymity over time. BlurMail focuses on temporary privacy with auto-expiring addresses that disappear completely, leaving no persistent aliases to manage or potentially leak.
Ease of Use
SimpleLogin requires account creation and has a learning curve for managing aliases, forwarding rules, and integrations. BlurMail requires no account at all. Just open the app, tap to create an address, and start receiving mail with push notifications.
Pricing
SimpleLogin offers a free tier with 10 aliases and a premium plan at $4 per month (or included with Proton Unlimited). BlurMail offers a free tier and affordable pro plans. SimpleLogin's free tier is more limited in alias count, while BlurMail's free tier covers most casual needs.
The Verdict
SimpleLogin and BlurMail serve different use cases. SimpleLogin is ideal for permanent email aliasing where you need ongoing anonymous communication. BlurMail is perfect for truly temporary addresses that you use once and let expire. Many privacy-conscious users benefit from having both.
| Feature | SimpleLogin | BlurMail |
|---|---|---|
| Native Mobile App | Yes (basic) | Yes (iOS + Android) |
| Push Notifications | Via real inbox | Yes, in-app |
| Auto-Expiring Addresses | No (permanent aliases) | Yes, customizable |
| No Account Required | No (account needed) | Yes |
| Reply via Alias | Yes | No |
| Open Source | Yes | No |
| Custom Domains | Yes (premium) | Coming Soon |
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I use BlurMail or SimpleLogin?
Use SimpleLogin for permanent email aliases where you need ongoing communication (like newsletters or accounts you plan to keep). Use BlurMail for truly temporary addresses that should disappear after use (like one-time sign-ups or trials).
Is SimpleLogin owned by Proton?
Yes, SimpleLogin was acquired by Proton in 2022. It integrates with Proton Mail and is included in the Proton Unlimited plan. BlurMail is an independent service focused on disposable email.
Protect Your Inbox Today
Generate anonymous, auto-expiring email addresses in seconds. No account needed.